nation of the period in which this emergence occurred Will Abu Bakr and 'Umar did not give their respective clansmen It is an historical fact that within a few years of 'Uthman's |
more intensely hated by the Kufans, whom he treated in The names of these distinguished Qur'an readers are to be In addition to appointing many of his clansmen to lucrative |
During the last few years of 'Uthman's reign, the major In this connection the speeches of Abu Dharr, frequently We must strongly dissent from the viewpoint of such |
forged and artificial. Such writers ignore the fact that these 'Ali's attitude towards the situation in this period is clearly "You were annoyed for the sake of God, so entertain hope from |
you. If you had accepted their world they would have loved you; Marwan reported the entire matter to 'Uthman, who After his acceptance of Abu Bakr and the subsequent |
the people on the one hand, and to extricate the Caliph from Two groups, different in outlook but with the same goals, It is an interesting phenomenon that both the hatred |
'Ali.(25) In addition to 'Ali's ardent supporters, Talha and The simmering discontent exploded into revolt in 35/656, In the confused atmosphere following the murder of the |
the form of an address delivered at the time of the battle of Al- "After 'Uthman was killed, you came to me saying that you Pressed by the demands from almost all quarters, 'Ali From the very start, 'Ali inherited great problems which The murder of 'Uthman was not a simple assassination |
had been the case in 'Umar's death. 'Uthman's murder was "...the murder of 'Uthman was an act of the days of ignorance Even Talha and Zubayr agreed on this point and said "the Before long, it became obvious that 'Ali's attempts to |
his authority included even 'A'isha, who refused to return to Having secured his position in Iraq for the moment, 'Ali The conflict of Siffin and the resulting arbitration have |
scholars, and it is not our purpose here to re-cover well- This entire period is discussed by 'Ali in the last part of his "In the end, the third of them ['Uthman] stood up shrugging "But when I took up the government, one group broke its "Nay, by Him who has split the seed and created the soul, but With this brief summary as a foundation, we will attempt |
the Prophet and resulted in the first civil war in Islam; but at An attempt to grasp the situation as a coherent whole Ya'qużbi records for us those speeches with which 'Ali was |
In the second place, there are numerous references in 'Thou art the noblest of the Quraysh in merit and religion. I see God arid the ftiture state through my love for 'Ali. 'Ali is the Aaron, 'Ali is the wasi.''(41) Still more informative is the fact that the term wanth appears Moreover, in reading the accounts of the battles of Al-Jamal Apart from these considerations, we have already seen that The purpose of the preceding discussion has been to |
thus it raised questions that had not arisen under the three "By God, they have shown their dislike against me for anything In the final analysis, it would appear that the vengeance for |
service of this group to revitalize itself and re-emerge in "I wish you could have been killed on the day of Jamal, and The conflict at the battle of Al-Jamal brought about a |
of the camel," or ashab al-jamal) and the Syrians (ahi ash- Throughout this period, however, the followers of 'Ali were |
at Siffin.(56) A few decades later, when the Shi'a started to The idea of these classes is certainly of a later date. |
Notes to Chapter 4
(1) Aghani VI, pp.334 f.; Mas'udi, Muruj, II, pp.342 f.
(2) Tabari, I, pp. 2948 f. For other versions, see Ibn Sa'd, III, 64; Baladhuri, V, p.25; Ya'qubi, II, pp.164 ff.; Dinawari, Akhbar, p.139; Mas'udi, Muruj; II, pp.334 ff.; 'Iqd, IV, pp. 280ff. (3) See Tabari, I, pp.29323; Mas'udi, Muruj, II, p.337 (4) Tabari, I, p. 2871 ; Baladhuri, V, p.49 (5) Baladhuri, V, pp.31 ff.; Tabari, I, p.2845; Mas'udi, Muruj, II, p.335; 'Iqd, IV, p.307 (6) Baladhuri, V, pp. 40 ff.; Mas'udi, Muruj, II, p.337; Tabari, I, pp. 2916 f. (7) Baladhuri, V. pp.27 f.; Tabari, I, pp.2953 f.; Ash'ari, Tamhid, p.99 (8) Baladhuri, V, pp.36 f.; Ya'qubi, II, p.170 (9) Baladhuri, V, pp. 48 f.; 'Iqd, IV, p.307. Also see Mowdudi, Abu'lA'la, Khilafai wa Mulukiyat, pp.105 ff., 321 if, which gives an admirable exposition of 'Uthman's weakness for his kinsmen and of their misdeeds. (10) Baladhuri, V, pp. 52 ff.; Tabari, I, pp. 2858 ff.; Mas'udi, Muruj, II, pp.339 ff.; Ya'qubi, II, p.171 (11) Ya'qubi, loc. cit. (12) For these comments see S. M. Yusuf, "The Revolt Against 'Uthman", Islamic Culture, XXVI I (1953), pp.4-5 (13) Baladhuri, V, pp. 26, 57; Tabari, I, pp.2955, 2980; 'Iqd, IV, p.280 (14) Baladhuri, V, pp. 53ff.; Mas'adi, Muruj, II, pp.34' f.; Ya'qubi, II, pp.172 f.; Iladid, Sharh, VIII, pp.252 ff. (15) Nahj al-Balagha, I, p.303 (16) Cf. sources in note 14 above (17) Baladhuri; V, pp. 26, 60-6I; Tabari, I, pp. 2948 f., pp.2955 ff.; Mas'udi, Muruj II, p.344; Ash'ari, Tamhid, p.54 (18) Baladhuri, V, p.40 (19) Kashshi, Rijal, p.72 (20) ibid., pp. 79-87 (21) ibid., pp. 75-78 (22) Tabari, I, p.2942; Ash'ari, Tamhid, pp.55 f. (23) Wa' az as-Salat'n (Baghdad, 1954), pp.148 ff. (24) Bernard Lewis, Origins of Isma'ilism (Cambridge, 1940), p.25; Marshal G. S. Hodgson, "How Did the Early Shi'a Become Sectarian ?" JAOS, LXXV (1955), p.2. For further sources, see EI2 article "Abd Allah b. Saba". |
(25) Hodgson, "Early Shi'a", p.3
(26) Baladhuri, V, p.49. The son of Abu Bakr, Muhammad was a devoted follower of 'Ali and a bitter critic of'Uthman. Cf. Hodgson, "Early Shi'a", p.2 (27) Baladhuri, V, pp.34, 48-49; Tabari, I, p.3112; Ya'qubi, II, p.175; Al-Imama wa's-Siyasa, I, p.30 (28) Baladhuri, V, pp.62 ff., 69; Tabari, I, pp. 2988 f.; Mas'udi, Muruj, II, p.232; 'Iqd, IV, p.290 (29) Baladhuri, V, pp.70 f.; Tabari, I, pp.3066 ff.; 'Iqd, IV, pp.291, 310 (30) 'Iqd, IV, p.318 (31) Baladhuri, V, p.70; Tabari, I, p.3068; Ya'qubi, II, p. 178; Ash'ari, Tamhid, p.107; Dinawari, Akhbar, p.140 (32) Tabari, I, p.3080 (33) Tabari, I, p.3127 (34) Tabari, I, pp. 309 I, 3112 if.; Ya'qubi, II, p. 180; Hadid, Sharh, I, p.232 (35) Tabari, I, p.3255 (36) 'Iqd, IV, p.334. Also see Baladhuri, IVA, p. 108, where some companions rejected Mu'awiya's right to call for the blood of 'Uthman while there were other nearer relatives of 'Uthman to claim it. (37) See Chapter 3, n. 8, above (38) Ya'qu hi, II, p.179 (39) Hodgson, "How Did the Early Shi'a Become Sectarian?", JAOS, p.2 (40) W. Montgomery Watt, "Shi'ism Under the Umayyads", JRAS, 196o, p. 161. Cf. 3. Ryckmans, L'institution monarchique en Arabia atant l'Islam (Louvain, 1951), pp.229 if. (41) Mubarrad, Kamil, III, p. 205; Mas'udi; Muruj, II, p.416; Aghani; XII, p.326. R. Strothmann agrees that there are distinguish- able religious honours accorded to 'Ali in the poetry of ad-Du'ali (cf. E11 article "Shl'a"). Also see similar verses composed by Kumayt and Kuthayyir in Mubarrad, Kamil, III, pp.204 f. (42) e.g. Qur'an, xIx, 6 (43) Hadid, Sharh, I, pp.144-9 (44) Ibn Nadim, Fihrist, p.93 (45) e.g. pp. 18,23 f., 43,49, 365, 382, 385. See also Askafi, Naqdal- 'Uthmaniya, p.84 (46) Baladhuri, V, p. 34. Even the verses of Ibn Umm Kilb attribute to 'A 'isha the responsibility for the murder of 'Uthman. Cf. Tabari, I, p 3112 (47) Mufid, Irshad, p.146; Nahj al-Balagha, I, p.63 (48) This incident is known as the Hadith al-Ifk, and Bukhari |
records a detailed account of it (See Sahih, III, pp. 25 ff). Cf. other hadith works under the heading "Hadith al-Ifk". (49) 'Umar Abu Nasr, 'Ali wa 'A'isha (Baghdad, n.d.), pp.25 ff (50) Mubarrad, Kamil, I, p.267 (51) These expressions are frequently used in the Arabic sources: e.g. Tabari I, pp.3196, 3199; Ya'qubI, II, pp.183, 183 199; Aghanz; XII, p.334; XIV, p.219 (52) Tabari, I, p.1272 (53) XLVIII, 10. See Iladid, Sharh, I, p.201 (54) LXXII, 15. See Iladid, loc. cit. (55) Hadid, loc. cit.; Ya'qubi, II, p.193 (56) Minqari; Waq'at Siffin, p.504; Tabari, I, pp.3336 f. (57) Fihrist, p.175; Tabari, II, p. 1; Kashshi, Rijal, pp.4 f. (58) Tabari, I,pp.3350 f. Cf. W. Montgomery Watt, "Shi'ism Under the Umayyads", JRAS (1960), pp. I60-161 |