( 391 )
This Saif Ibn Omar was one of the forgers of the
hadiths and the reports of the events of history. The
Muslim scholars who are specialized in Hadith have expressed their opinion about Saif:
Ibn Mu-een (died in 277) said: Saif is a weak reporter.
Al-Nisa-i (died in 303) said: Saif is a weak reporter.
Abu Dawood (died in 317) said: Saif is nothing.
Al-Hakim (died in 405) said: Saif is abandoned and accused of being heretic.
Ibn Hayyan said: Saif reportedly forged stories and attributed them to reliable reporters
and he was accused of being heretic.
Al-Dar Qutni (died in 385) said: Saif is a weak reporter
and was abandoned.
Ibn Hajar (died 850) said: Saif is a weak reporter.(48)
This Saif reported many Hadiths which are opposed to
the well known facts of history and to the facts which are
reported by numerous reliable reporters. He also reported
events which are inconceivable.
The resentment of Ali towards the election of Abu
Bakr was reported by outstanding hadith-reporters
and
this is known to the students of history. What Al-Tabari
reported through Saif Ibn Omar about Ali's election of
Abu Bakr is the following:
"Ali was at his house when he was informed that Abu
Bakr is receiving the pledge of allegiance. Ali hurriedly left
his home without having his cloak on him because he did
not like to lose time. He came to the mosque and pledged
his allegiance to Abu Bakr then sat with him and sent
after his cloak. When it was brought to him he put it on
and remained with Abu Bakr." (49)
It is a well known fact of history which was reported
( 48 ) Sayed Murtadha Al-Askari in his book Abdullah Ibn Saba p. 26.
( 49 ) Al-Tabari his History part 3 (Event in the 11th year A.
H.) p. 201 (conveyed by Sayed Al-Askari Abdullah Ibn Saba)
|